Pinecroft Dairy – West Boylston MA

31 05 2009

Since starting this blog eleven months ago, nearly all of my friends who aren’t lactose intolerant have told me great tales of the ice cream place that they always went to growing up. Quite often those memories are a bit blurred, or else history hasn’t been kind and all that remains is a sputtering soft-serve machine. Sometimes the results are far better like with this Bear Claw cone.

pinecroft dairy west boylston ma ice cream

Pinecroft was a dairy located in West Boylston. The idyllic nature of this place has been tempered by parking lots and nearby developments that have left just a single restaurant building standing. It’s still difficult to get to, especially without any signage along Route 12 that directs people when and where to turn to find a cone. I opted for both a map and a cell phone to find my way to this ice cream.

Established back in 1952, Pinecroft is similar to a place like Cabot’s in Newtonville – a single store that divides its attentions between family dining and ice cream. Think Friendly’s without the excess of franchising and a greater focus on ice cream. Apparently this used to be atop a hill surrounded by cows and other farm elements (the land was used as a dairy even before they started making ice cream), but all that’s around to see is the store itself and an odd grassy knoll with a porch swing and a picnic bench and a mini waterfall.

Inside there is ample seating for people who want a meal or ice cream (though if you’re just looking for ice cream, I’d bet that dinner customers get priority. Outside is an array of windows offering ice cream to the steady stream of people who pull up on this Sunday evening. The inside closes an hour before the windows, so folks are heading off to their cars to eat since the sun is dancing on the horizon and the wind has been whipping that chill into the air.

I started with a sample of the Ginger ice cream, which was both bold and subtle and would have made a great full cone, but I was tempted by the unknown and went with bear claw ice cream. I’m not quite sure how the name applies as usually a bear claw is the almondy cousin of an apple fritter, but I won’t complain much with what is offered here. Starting with a chocolate ice cream base that is light and smooth and very milky as opposed to creamy, the ice cream also has a thick swirl of caramel and then is peppered with chocolate-covered cashews. The combination is heavenly without being too rich, and the mix of flavors brings something fresh to each bite. It’s a great ice cream that doesn’t leave you weighted down afterwards. I only wonder how nice it would have been after a plate of grilled cheese and french fries.

bear claw ice cream pinecroft dairy west boylston ma

My issue today is with cone assembly. The picture above was the first attempt, and as I turned the cone to get a better angle, the entire heap of ice cream started to sway and topple. I caught it in time, but since i used my mouth and took a bite in order to save it, a picture was no longer an option. The problem was that none of the ice cream that was scooped was actually inside the cone. With summer work starting their first days there are lots of teens who are just learning to scoop and this is not the first time this spring that I’ve encountered such precariousness.

Cone – regular $3.50 large $3.95 super $4.50

Sundae $5.50

Frappe $5

Pinecroft Restaurant and Dairy

539 Prospect St, West Boylston, MA 01583

508 853-0717

Open year round

Sunday-Wednesday 11:30a-9p, Thursday-Saturday 11:30a-10p (inside closes an hour earlier)

Pinecroft online


Jimmies – Roslindale MA

29 05 2009

Truth be told, I don’t know much of Roslindale, except a song by that name that the Rudds had. I’m actually pretty certain that I’ve never gone there before intentionally. With today’s Twilight Zone episode of a trip, I’m not sure that any repeat plans are in the works. After this review, I’m not wholly sure that I’d be welcome anyway. I did find a Maple Walnut cone, but …

Jimmies Ice Cream Roslindale MA

Jimmies is a brand new ice cream joint in Roslindale Village. It used to be a photo shop, but with the advent of digital photography and no one needing to develop film, owner Donna Cabral closed up shop and started from scratch with this new endeavor. The official opening was earlier this month, though in truth it  still seems as though they aren’t settled in yet.

The name of the store comes from Cabral’s fond remembrance of the chocolate sprinkles of yore (even if her tale does stray a bit from the actual reality of where the word comes from: while some parlors may have donated the proceeds from that addition to the Jimmy Fund, jimmies are actually named after the guy who invented them). The result is an odd sign that lacks the possessive punctuation that you expect from shoppes with people’s names in the title. The store itself is crammed with a large counter and four tables and little space to navigate around other customers cluttering the area, with a single wooden bench located in front.

The ice cream isn’t made in Roslindale. In fact, it’s another shoppe that has fallen under the umbrella of Richardson’s. While the Middletown based manufacturer makes a nice ice cream, when you work on a spectrum of homemade ice creams, this is really a baseline, a control if you will, to measure other ice creams next to. It’s kind of disappointing to make such efforts to find a new spot only to encounter tastes that are already known.

I tasted the Green Monster (which is just a Grasshopper – mint and chocolate) and Rum Raisin (a tart alcoholic front without much finish), but neither really swayed me so I opted for maple walnut in a sugar cone. Unaccustomed to people providing all the necessary information with brevity, I had to repeat my desire for a sugar cone three times. The maple was syrupy sweet, but lacking that woody kick, and the walnuts weren’t fresh or really much of anything but placeholders. Nothing is as frustrating as a cone that doesn’t satisfy, and while there was nothing wrong, the fact was that a slew of things kept this from succeeding.

maple walnut ice cream jimmies roslindale ma

I tried to salvage my trip and feed my hunger with pizza while I was in this neighborhood, but somehow I failed even more ingloriously. I can’t recall the last time I had to spit up some pizza, but the Sicilian slices I got at Romano’s had a gummy tasteless texture and meat on top that was chewier than jerky. Somehow I spent my afternoon on what some people deem an impossibility – bad ice cream and pizza.

Cone – kiddie $2 regular $3.50 large $4.50

Sundae – regular $3.75 large $4.50

Frappe $3.99

Jimmies Ice Cream & Sandwiches

48A Corinth St, Roslindale, MA 02131

857 719-6665

Open year round

Sunday-Thursday 11a-9p, Friday & Saturday 11a-10p

Jimmies online

Ice Cream Stimulus

8 05 2009

Edy’s seems to be going all out in the contest department this year. Neighborhood ice cream socials are one thing, but providing essentially a $100,000 grant to someone is a whole nother matter. That seems just like what they are doing with an open online application looking for someone with a worthy plan for what to do with an infusion of cash and how you can turn and help the community.


Go online to and follow the instructions to apply for their contribution to economic recovery. All you need to do is fill out the application and come up with the best 150 word answers to three questions: “Why are you entering to win an opportunity to be Edy’s® “A Taste of Recovery” Spokesperson and $100,000? Tell us why you deserve and/or need this money, and How would you spend the $100,000 to pursue your dream?”

Ice Cream Club – Auburndale MA

5 05 2009

My quest for the day brought me to Auburndale in search of the Lasell College bookstore to find a shirt for my aunt’s birthday. Thanks to the internet, my brother in Chicago was able to help lead me there (though as a result, I sat in front of the building talking to my nephew for half an hour before heading in). Just down the road, I was pleased to find myself a Black And Tan sugar cone.

ice cream club newton auburndale mass

Back in December, I had made efforts to come over to Ice Cream Club when I found an article about the place being up for sale. It thus a pleasant surprise to find that the lights were on as I drove past. With no apparent suitors, it was nice to discover that the Schaffer’s had opened back up for the 2009 season.

This location has been a Newton area tradition dating back over twenty years when this site was the home of another ice cream parlor named The Ice Cream Man. The shop has been run by the Schaffer family the past few years and all of the kids worked there as their after-school jobs. With the kids now off to college, that’s why they’ve been seeking new ownership. Unfortunately, it was busy and I didn’t get to ask many questions to find out what the current status is, but the for sale sign is not in the front window anymore.

The shop is decked out in record covers and other rock ‘n’ roll ephemera so that it almost feels like the inside of a jukebox. The silver tables and chairs bring that fifties soda fountain feel to this spot. With six indoor tables, two outside, and park benches within view of the front door, this is a very relaxed spot, especially given that it’s so near the confluence of so many major roads.

After a taste of the Grasshopper, I realized my tongue was still attuned to the spearmint of juleps rather than peppermint flavors, and opted for a black and tan cone. This ice cream isn’t a combination of beer flavors, but it does have the half-and-half aspect of the colors colliding, but not blending. It’s a caramel ice cream with a chocolate cookie swirl that also has chocolate covered candy crunch in it. The cream flavors are very subtle and the caramel is just there to bring you the chocolates which make the biggest impact. A sweet cone and here’s hoping there are still scoops in this spot twenty years from now.

black and tan ice cream club auburndale ma newton

It wasn’t until it was too late and I was already dropping globs from my cone onto the tiled floor that I realized that had I wanted, I could have got jimmies on my cone for free. While there are usually lots of toppings (and an equally long set of names for each depending on where you are), this is the first time that I noticed anyone offering them for free. For those reading this who are not from New England, despite what you may have heard, jimmies is not vestigial Jim Crow slang, it’s actually named for the guy that invented them and so is more like Kleenex. Dang, maybe I have to pay someone a copyright for just typing the word jimmies.

Cone – small $2.99 medium $3.75 large $4.50 jumbo $5.50

Sundae – small $3.99 medium $4.99 large $5.99 jumbo $6.99

Frappe $4.95 malt +$.30

Ice Cream Club

419 Lexington St, Auburndale, MA 02466

617 244-3555

Open April-October

Monday-Thursday noon-9p, Friday-Saturday noon-10p, Sunday noon-8p

Ice Cream Club online